RoHS material control Vietnam country-of-origin documentation rfq@saolamfg.comEmail WhatsApp +84 86 501 7914

Guide

Optical comparator, vision measuring machine or CMM: which should inspect your part?

Short answer

An optical comparator is an instrument that projects a magnified shadow or surface image of a part onto a large screen, where it is compared with an overlay chart or measured by moving a precision stage; it is also called a profile projector. Short answer: use a comparator or a 2D vision measuring machine for profiles, radii, thread forms, small holes and positions that lie in one plane, and require a CMM (or a functional gauge) when the drawing ties features to a 3D datum reference frame, depths or surfaces facing different directions; the vision machine is the better choice of the two 2D tools when you need many points, repeatability and a printed report.

By Saola Manufacturing engineering team · Published · Updated

How a CMM works and how to read its report is covered in CMM inspection. This guide compares the three tools from the buyer's side: what each is good at, how its accuracy is stated, and what to write in the PO.

On this page

How do an optical comparator and a vision measuring machine differ?

A comparator shows the operator a magnified image and relies on the operator to align edges with a screen line or chart; a vision measuring machine uses a camera and software to find edges, then calculates features from many points. Both measure in the plane of the image.

On a comparator, a part on the stage is lit from behind (contour or transmitted illumination) to throw a sharp silhouette, or from the front (surface or reflected illumination) to show features on a face. The operator either lays a magnified chart of the nominal profile over the screen, which makes a fast go/no-go check of a form, or moves the stage between edges and reads the displacement. Mitutoyo's metrology institute notes that magnification accuracy affects measurements made across the screen, while stage length accuracy affects measurements made by moving the stage, and squareness of the axes adds error when both axes move (Mitutoyo Institute of Metrology, Accuracy of Profile Projectors).

A vision measuring machine replaces the screen and operator's eye with a camera, lighting control and edge-detection software. It fits circles, lines and arcs to many detected points, so a hole diameter or a radius comes from a fit rather than from one operator's judgment, and the measuring routine can be programmed and repeated lot after lot. Some machines add a touch probe or a height sensor, but a plain 2D vision system still measures what it sees from above.

Which features does each instrument measure well?

Comparators and vision machines excel at outlines: profiles, radii, chamfers, angles, slots, small holes and hole patterns seen from one direction. CMMs are needed when features must be related to datums in three dimensions.

The table is a practical guide for matching a drawing feature to an instrument. It is general industry guidance; the right answer for a specific tolerance also depends on the instrument's stated accuracy, discussed in the next section.

Feature-to-instrument guide · industry guidance; comparator accuracy characteristics per JIS B 7184:1999, vision CMM acceptance per ISO 10360-7:2011
Drawing featureOptical comparator2D vision machineCMM
Turned profile, radii, chamfers, thread formGood (overlay chart)GoodPossible, slower
Small holes and slots in a thin flat partFairGoodGood if probe fits
Hole pattern position in one planeFair (stage moves)GoodGood
Position to datums on different facesPoorPoorGood
Depths, step heights, perpendicularity to a facePoorLimited (needs height sensor)Good
Soft, tiny or delicate partsGood (no contact)Good (no contact)Risky with contact probe
Many parts, same program, printed reportOperator-dependentGoodGood

How accurate are optical comparators and vision machines?

Accuracy is stated per instrument as a length error that grows with the measured length, plus a magnification error for screen measurements. Ask for the stated values and the calibration certificate, not a single “accuracy” number.

Mitutoyo's bulletin says that no international or American national standard specifies profile projectors, and it uses the Japanese standard JIS B 7184:1999 as the technical basis. Its default specifications per JIS B 7184 are a stage length accuracy of (6 + 0.04L) µm with L in mm, magnification accuracy of 0.15% for contour illumination and 0.25% for surface illumination, and a squareness term, all at 20°C, and it notes that a manufacturer may state different values (Mitutoyo EDU-15002A). Per JIS B 7184, the percentages apply to the length of the feature on the part, so a 0.15% error on a 20 mm feature is far larger than the same percentage on a 2 mm feature.

For vision machines, the relevant acceptance test is ISO 10360-7:2011, which specifies acceptance and reverification tests for Cartesian coordinate measuring machines with imaging probing systems working in discrete-point mode (ISO 10360-7:2011). Contact-probe CMMs are tested under ISO 10360-2 instead. In both cases, the useful question to a supplier is: what is the stated maximum permissible error of this machine, when was it last verified, and how does that compare with the tolerance? The gauge accuracy guide covers how much of the tolerance the instrument may use.

What does an inspection report from each instrument look like?

A comparator report is usually hand-recorded readings or a pass/fail against a chart; a vision or CMM report is a printout per feature with nominal, measured value, deviation and pass/fail. Ask for the format you need before the first article.

For a comparator check against an overlay chart, the record is often just “profile within chart limits”, which proves conformance but gives no numbers for trend analysis. If you want numbers, ask for stage readings on the listed dimensions. A vision machine's program produces the same feature list every time, which suits a first-article inspection report with balloon numbers and a dimensional inspection record for each lot. Whatever the instrument, the report should identify it, its calibration status, the operator, the date and the part or lot it belongs to.

Lighting and edge settings change results on a vision machine, especially on chamfered edges, burrs and shiny turned surfaces. For disputed dimensions, ask the supplier how the edge was defined (contour or surface light, which edge of a chamfer), so both sides measure the same thing.

When should a PO require a CMM instead of 2D optical measurement?

Require a CMM, or an agreed equivalent such as a functional gauge, when a characteristic depends on a 3D datum reference frame, on depth or on features in different planes. For 2D outlines and in-plane positions, optical measurement is usually adequate and often better.

Write the requirement against the characteristic, not the machine. For example: “Position of holes A1–A4 to datums A|B|C: measurement method to be agreed at first article” is better than “CMM report required” on every dimension, because it lets the supplier use a height gauge, a gauge or a vision program where they are valid and keeps CMM time for what needs it. The height gauge guide shows what can be done on a surface plate without a CMM.

  • Profile of a turned form, thread form, small radii: comparator or vision.
  • Hole pattern in a flat plate, slot widths, small hole diameters: vision.
  • Hole positions to datums on different faces, perpendicularity of a bore to a face: CMM or functional gauge.
  • Thin, soft or tiny parts: non-contact optical measurement.

What measuring equipment does Saola's lead plant use?

The lead CNC plant inspects with a 2D optical (vision) measuring instrument, a height gauge and a hardness tester, and it has no CMM. Characteristics that need a CMM are raised at drawing review.

That equipment fits the turned and milled parts described on the CNC turning and CNC milling pages, where most critical features are diameters, profiles, threads and in-plane positions; threads are checked with go/no-go gauges. New parts get a first-article inspection report and each lot a dimensional inspection record. If your drawing has 3D datum relationships that need a CMM, we will flag them at drawing review and agree a method, such as a functional gauge or third-party measurement, before quoting. Send the drawing through the quote form.

Frequently asked

Is an optical comparator the same as a profile projector?

Yes. Mitutoyo's bulletin uses both names for the same instrument.

Is a vision measuring machine a CMM?

In standards terms, yes: ISO 10360-7 treats it as a coordinate measuring machine with an imaging probing system. In shop language, “CMM” usually means a contact-probe machine that measures in 3D.

Can a comparator check a thread?

It can check thread form, pitch and flank angles on an external thread with an overlay chart. Fit to class is still checked with thread gauges.

How often should these instruments be calibrated?

There is no single required interval; it is set by the user's quality system and usage. Ask for the date and result of the last calibration and the standards it was traced to.

Sources

  1. Accuracy of Profile Projectors (EDU-15002A), Mitutoyo America Corporation, Mitutoyo Institute of Metrology, 2017 (summarizes JIS B 7184:1999)
  2. ISO 10360-7:2011, Acceptance and reverification tests for CMMs equipped with imaging probing systems, ISO, 2011 (confirmed 2021)

Have a drawing for this? Send it for a quote.

STEP or PDF, one part or a whole family. You get a unit price at your volume, the tooling cost, and a short manufacturability note.