Guide
What are die casting surface finish classes, and which one should your drawing call out?
Die casting surface finish classes are the graded levels of as-cast appearance that a buyer and a die caster agree on before quoting, from a surface where visible imperfections are acceptable up to one held to a measured roughness value. In North America the reference is the five-step As-Cast Surface scale in the NADCA Product Specification Standards for Die Castings, which runs from Utility Grade to Superior Grade.
By Saola Manufacturing engineering team · Published · Updated
This guide covers the NADCA grades, the grade each downstream finish tends to need, and how to mark cosmetic zones on a drawing. The grade names come from NADCA; the advice on matching and marking is general engineering practice, not a statement of any one shop’s results.
On this page
What are the five NADCA as-cast surface grades?
NADCA’s Casting Surface Finishing checklist, C-8-2, grades the as-cast surface from 1 to 5: Utility, Functional, Commercial, Consumer and Superior. Each step up asks more of the die, the process and the inspection, and the checklist states that the lowest number is the most economical basis for production.
| Grade | What the checklist says | Where it usually fits |
|---|---|---|
| 1 — Utility | Surface imperfections are acceptable; for nondecorative coatings | Internal brackets, hidden housings, parts left bare or given a protective conversion coat |
| 2 — Functional | Slight surface imperfections that can be removed; heavier coatings | Parts that will carry a thick paint or powder film that hides minor marks |
| 3 — Commercial | Imperfections that can be removed | Visible but not decorative faces where some dressing before coating is acceptable |
| 4 — Consumer | No objectionable imperfections, as agreed, under normal lighting at a stated viewing distance | Customer-facing faces on consumer and appliance products; decorative coating or plating |
| 5 — Superior | A specified average surface finish value in microinches, per print | Faces that are polished and electroplated, or where a measured texture is the requirement |
Two details in the checklist wording matter more than the names. Consumer Grade is not a measurement; it is a visual judgment, and the checklist leaves a blank for the viewing distance so that buyer and caster fix it in writing. Superior Grade is the only grade that is a number, and the checklist leaves that number blank as well, to be taken from the part print. In both cases, a grade written on a drawing without the blank filled in is only half a specification.
The checklist points to NADCA guideline G-6-6 in the same manual for the fuller definitions, and it is published as a form that the buyer may reproduce and attach to a request for quotation (NADCA, commercial practices and checklists).
Which as-cast grade does each downstream finish need?
Choose the grade by what will cover the surface: a thick paint or powder film forgives more, a thin conversion coat or anodic film forgives less, and bright electroplate forgives almost nothing. As a rule, decorative plating needs the top of the scale, while protective coatings can start at the bottom.
The NADCA production checklist, C-8-1, makes the same split in its own short list of cast surface finish levels: mechanical quality where finish is not significant, painting quality where streaks and chill areas can be covered with paint, and highest quality for electroplating, decorative finishing and O-ring seats. A seal face and a chrome-plated face need the same thing from the casting: a dense surface free of laps and pits.
For zinc, the International Zinc Association’s design guidance states that the surface of a zinc die casting to be electroplated “must be substantially free of surface defects” (IZA, polishing and plating). Plating copies the surface beneath it, and a bright nickel-chrome layer makes a cold lap or a flow line more visible, not less. Decorative copper-nickel-chromium systems on zinc and aluminum alloys are specified per ASTM B456, which grades the coating by service condition; the casting grade has to be good enough for the coating grade chosen.
Powder coating sits in the middle. It covers well, but the same zinc guidance notes that it thins at sharp outside corners and coats poorly inside cup and box shapes (IZA, powder coating). A Functional or Commercial surface is often enough under powder on flat, open faces, while edges and pockets on a visible face deserve a closer look. For how the coatings themselves compare, see the anodizing, powder coating and zinc plating guide.
Many zinc parts need no applied finish at all. The IZA notes that most zinc die castings go into service uncoated, either as cast or after an inexpensive vibratory treatment (IZA, general comments on finishing), and that textured die surfaces hide small imperfections and help prevent minor defects such as cold laps (IZA, as-cast finishes). If a visible face can carry a texture, specifying one is often a cheaper route to a consistent look than asking for a higher grade on a smooth face.
How is Superior Grade specified when it is a roughness value?
Superior Grade is written as an average roughness value on the print, and NADCA’s checklist gives it in microinches. On a drawing that means an Ra callout with its unit, placed only on the faces that need it, together with the measurement method.
Roughness parameters and their measurement are defined in ASME B46.1 for US drawings and in the ISO 21920 series for ISO drawings. State Ra explicitly rather than an older RMS note, since RMS describes a different parameter (Rq). The roughness conversion table in the ISO 2768 and NADCA tolerances guide converts between micrometers, microinches and old N-grades.
Measuring a cast surface is not the same as measuring a machined one. Cast surfaces carry texture and waviness from the die steel, draft on side walls, and local marks near gates and ejector pins. Agree where the stylus trace is taken, in which direction, and on how many parts per lot, or the same casting can pass at the supplier and fail at incoming inspection.
How do you mark A, B and C surfaces on a die-casting drawing?
Divide the part into zones by visibility, label them on the drawing, and give each zone its own NADCA grade and inspection condition. Most drawings use A for the surface the end user sees, B for surfaces seen occasionally, and C for hidden or internal faces.
The letters are a drafting convention, not a NADCA term, so define them in a note on the drawing rather than assuming the supplier reads them the way you do. ASME Y14.8, the standard for drawings of castings, forgings and molded parts, gives the framework for casting-specific callouts; the zone note sits on top of it. A workable note looks like this:
- Zone A (shaded on the view): NADCA as-cast surface Grade 4, Consumer, inspected under normal lighting at an agreed viewing distance; parting line polished flush; no ejector pin marks.
- Zone B: NADCA Grade 3, Commercial; imperfections removable before coating.
- Zone C (all other surfaces): NADCA Grade 1, Utility.
The NADCA finishing checklist is built to accept this kind of marking. Its parting-line line item offers “polish only where marked on drawing”, and its surface preparation item offers “buff as indicated on drawing”. Shading the A zone on one view and referencing it in both places keeps the drawing and the checklist in agreement.
Zone marking also tells the die designer where not to put things. Gates, overflows, vents and ejector pins all leave marks, and the zinc guidance recommends positioning parting lines, gates, vents, overflows and ejectors to avoid marks on the finished face. If the A zone is known before the die is designed, those features can be kept on B and C surfaces.
What other checklist items change how a cast surface looks?
The surface grade is one line on the NADCA checklists; flash removal, ejector pin treatment, parting line polishing and surface preparation are separate lines. Each one changes what the part looks like on arrival, so leave none of them blank.
| Checklist item | Options, lowest cost first |
|---|---|
| C-8-1 B, cast surface finish | Mechanical quality; painting quality; highest quality for electroplating, decorative finishing, O-ring seats |
| C-8-1 C, flash at the parting line | Break off gates and overflows only; die trimmed to an agreed distance; hand filed or polished flush; customer-defined deburring or blasting |
| C-8-1 E, ejector pin flash | Not removed; crushed or flattened; removed at specified locations |
| C-8-2 L, parting lines | No polishing; polish only where marked; polish all parting lines |
| C-8-2 M, surface preparation | No buffing; mechanical such as burnishing or tumbling; buff as marked |
| C-8-2 N and O, special finish and paint | Protective only; decorative; severe exposure or special base coat |
Read the two checklists together. A part ordered at Consumer Grade but with “break off gates only” and “ejector pin flash not removed” will arrive with gate stubs and raised witness marks, and every one of those answers is correct per the checklist.
Why does a higher surface grade change the quote?
Every step up the scale adds work somewhere: tighter control of die temperature and spray, more die polishing and maintenance, more sorting, and more hand finishing. NADCA’s checklist says as much by numbering its options so that the lowest number is the lowest production cost.
The zinc design guidance goes further. It notes that finishing such as buffing, polishing or vibratory treatment, together with plating, can account for over half of total product cost, and that where finishing costs are high it usually pays to make the casting more suitable for finishing rather than to chase the last fraction off the casting price (IZA, polishing and plating; IZA, surface finishing economics). In practice, that means the grade should be set together with the finisher, not by the casting buyer alone.
The cheapest improvement is almost always a narrower A zone: a part graded Consumer on every surface is priced as if every surface were inspected and dressed. For the aluminum alloy side, see the ADC12 and A380 alloy guide.
How should you specify cosmetic grade when the die caster is overseas?
Write the grade, the zone map and the inspection conditions into the RFQ, and back them with physical or photographic limit samples agreed before production. A visual grade that exists only in a conversation will be read differently on each side of an ocean.
- Attach the ticked NADCA checklists. NADCA explicitly permits reproducing them as part of an RFQ, and they give both sides the same vocabulary whether the supplier is in Vietnam, Mexico or the US.
- Fill in the blanks, then go further. The checklist leaves the viewing distance blank for Consumer Grade and the roughness value for Superior Grade. It does not cover the light source or how long an inspector looks at each part, so agree those, and the roughness measurement method, in writing.
- Agree limit samples. Keep a signed accept sample and a signed reject sample for each A zone at both ends, so incoming inspection compares parts to the same reference.
- Say who finishes. If the caster ships to a separate plater or coater, state which grade is checked at which stage, so a surface rejected after plating can be traced back.
At Saola Manufacturing, die casting in ADC12 aluminum and Zamak 3 zinc and surface finishing are done by partner plants we manage, and casting grade and finish are reviewed on the same drawing before either is placed; the quote names where each step is done. See the die casting and surface finishing pages. The RFQ package guide covers the rest of what to send. When the drawing is marked, send it for a quote; any zone or grade that needs discussion is raised in the reply.
Frequently asked
Where is NADCA guideline G-6-6?
It is in the NADCA Product Specification Standards for Die Castings, the same manual that contains the C-8-2 checklist, which refers to it for the as-cast surface grades. The manual is sold by NADCA; the checklists themselves are free to download.
Does shot blasting or tumbling change the grade?
They change the finished surface, not the as-cast grade. Blasting and vibratory finishing can hide or remove minor marks, which is why the checklist lists mechanical preparation as its own line. Specify the grade for the as-cast part and the preparation separately.
Can one part carry more than one grade?
Yes, and most should. Grade the visible face high, the hidden faces low, and mark the boundary on the drawing. That keeps cost where the appearance actually matters.
What if the face will be machined after casting?
Then the as-cast grade on that face hardly matters; the machined finish is what the customer sees. Mark it as a machined surface with its own roughness callout and leave the cast grade for the faces that stay as cast.
Sources
- Checklist C-8-2-21, Casting Surface Finishing Specifications, NADCA Product Specification Standards for Die Castings, 2021
- Checklist C-8-1-21, Casting Production Specifications, NADCA Product Specification Standards for Die Castings, 2021
- Commercial practices and checklists, NADCA, accessed September 2026
- Polishing and plating, International Zinc Association, zinc die casting design guidance, 2016
- General comments on finishing, International Zinc Association, 2016
- As cast finishes, International Zinc Association, 2016
- Powder coating, International Zinc Association, 2016
- Surface finishing economics, International Zinc Association, 2016
- ASTM B456-17(2022), Electrodeposited Coatings of Copper Plus Nickel Plus Chromium and Nickel Plus Chromium, ASTM International, 2022
- ASME Y14.8-2022, Castings, Forgings, and Molded Parts, ASME, 2022
- ASME B46.1-2019, Surface Texture (Surface Roughness, Waviness, and Lay), ASME, 2019